Year 5 students embrace the art of debating
POSTED November 29 2023 , News
St Mary’s Junior School has embraced the art of persuasion and critical thinking with the launch of its Year 5 Debating Club, spearheaded by enthusiastic Year 5 teacher, Jess O’Nions.
What started as a trial cocurricular offering has blossomed into a vibrant club that is not only expanding but also refining the skills of its young members.
O’Nions said that she was thrilled with the girls’ response to the club.
“I wasn’t sure how popular it would be compared to some of the other cocurricular offerings that we provide, but the girls were eager to participate.”
The response was overwhelming, with 35 students eagerly signing up for the club.
The focus of the program goes beyond mere verbal sparring, it is about fine-tuning persuasive techniques and structuring convincing arguments.
O’Nions said that she carefully selected debate topics that struck a balance between the familiar and subjects that required additional research.
“The girls have explored statements like, ‘Zoos do more harm than good’, ‘Every classroom should have a therapy dog’, ‘Space exploration is a total waste of money’ and many other thought-provoking topics,” O’Nions said.
Crucially, the program has also challenged students to argue against their personal beliefs—a pivotal aspect of debating.
O’Nions said that it was remarkable to witness the students’ growth throughout Terms 3 and 4.
“Their development in such a short timeframe has been incredible,” she said.
“From struggling with three-minute speeches to confidently formulating arguments on the fly, the girls have come a long way.
“At the end of each term, we have done a showcase where all the Years 5s gather and watch the girls do their final debate. They have really embraced those opportunities to demonstrate their newfound skills.
“Moreover, the benefits extend beyond the club. I have seen the girls utilise the skills that they have acquired in the debating club and apply them to their work in the classroom, particularly in speaking, listening and persuasive writing.”
The Year 5 debating club isn’t merely about winning arguments—it’s about nurturing critical thinkers, articulate communicators and confident young leaders.
Under O’Nions’ guidance, these girls are honing skills that will serve them well beyond their academic years.